Senator Lindsey Graham wants to impose mandatory detention of any immigrant who overstays a visa. At present, 230,000 immigrants are detained for one violation or another and 63 have died while being held in prisons since 2004. The Graham solution fits in perfectly with Republican hysteria about immigrants and terrorism. Actually, could any Republican provide some examples of exactly how many, if any, immigrants have been arrested and convicted for being terrorists?
People have immigrated to America for hundreds of years, and many, for one reason or another overstayed a visa. We currently have over a million foreign students in this country and we can assume X percent overstay their visa for legitimate or lazy reasons. If we adopt Senator Graham’s plan, it will be a bonanza for those who wish to build prisons since we would need quite a few more Guantanamos in this country rather than in Cuba. Or, maybe Senator Graham wants to send hundreds of thousands of detained immigrants to Cuba.
America is rapidly gaining a reputation as having a Not Welcome sign to visitors. Visitors are responsible for billions of dollars of revenue, and if we continue taking negative attitudes we will lose that source of revenue. I suspect if anyone examined his or her immigrant history examples would crop up of a distant relative who overstayed a visa or broke one or another immigration rule. My uncle entered this country illegally and turned out to be a decent citizen.