Holocaust Denial Takes New Twist

The history of the Holocaust has been detailed in thousands of books, memoirs and films that make clear to any normal human that Nazi Germany was guilty of an unspeakable horror in its murderous campaign against innocent people. As one who helped found a Holocaust Museum, there was ongoing discussion concerning the need to make part of its content, the story of what happened to gays, Romas and millions of others who were murdered by German forces. No Holocaust Center ever attempts to present a version of the Holocaust in which only Jews are victims. Archbishop Dadeus Grings from Porto Alegre in southern Brazil only added to the problems of Pope Benedict by becoming the second Catholic bishop to create a Holocaust issue for the Church where none should exist. The bishop said: “The Jews talk about six million people killed. But, how many Catholics were victims of the Holocaust?” He went on to add: “Jews say they were the main victims of the Holocaust, the biggest victims were the gypsies, because they were exterminated.”

It insults those who died in the Holocaust or anyone who died as a result of German action to get into the “numbers game” as to who “suffered the most.” How does one measure “suffering?” This is a ridiculous discussion. Over thirty million Russians died, Jews as well as Christians. Millions of Catholics died as did Protestants and atheists. The only way to respond to the ignorance of this Catholic bishop is –silence. Pope Benedict has spoken eloquently about the Holocaust and it insults the Catholic Church and those who have worked for reconciliation to allow this ignorant man from Brazil to assume his comments have any worth or any standing in his church.

  • http://UnitedKingdom John

    In reply to Archbishop Dadeus Grings all I can say is this.Like Bishop Williamson, Dadeus Grings only expressed an opnion. I am wondering which is the greater sin,to deny some aspects of the holocaust,or to deny that Our Lord Jesus Christ is God. What an outcry there would be if some country were to prosecute and gaol anyone who denied that Christ is God and was sent by God to redeem the world. All this media driven onslaught on people who deny some parts of the Holocaust says more about the corrupt liberal Jewish and Catholic”elites” than the state of the Church.

  • http://www.theimpudentobserver.com Fred Stopsky

    I am lost. No one denies the good bishop his right to proclaim what he wants about Jesus Christ. But, when he utters nonsense about the Holocaust, some people who believe in the truth get upset.